My dad knew English as a second language. But his use of idioms far exceeded mine. He had a saying that some might apply to this topic. He would say, “Everything comes out in the wash.” While that may be a natural response to the question of what time of year you should take your RMD, many issues, such as tax implications, penalties, and investment growth, make it worth spending additional time understanding it more deeply.
IRA owners who are 73 years old (75 for those born in 1960 or later) and older are subject to Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs) and generally have flexibility over when during the year they take the distribution. Some take it early in the year, others receive monthly distributions, and many wait until late in the year.1
This can seem like an easy question to do a Google search, refer to an AI model, ask your neighbor…etc. However, there isn’t one approach that’s right for everyone. That is an aspect that can easily get missed when referring to these other sources for answers. The better question is: What timing best fits your financial plan?
The argument for waiting
One traditional reason for waiting until late in the year is to keep money inside the IRA growing tax-deferred for as long as possible. If the retiree doesn’t need the RMD for living expenses, the distribution can generally be reinvested in a taxable account after it is received. The money therefore doesn’t necessarily stop growing simply because it leaves the IRA. Instead, the question becomes where the investment growth occurs and how that growth will eventually be taxed.
For example, bonds and other tax-inefficient investments may benefit more from remaining inside an IRA, while appreciation on stocks held in a taxable account may eventually qualify for long-term capital-gains treatment or potentially receive a step-up in basis at death.
Taking the RMD earlier can reduce investment risk
Suppose a retiree knows that $30,000 of the year’s RMD will be needed for living expenses.
Rather than leaving that $30,000 invested in the stock market until December, the retiree could take the distribution earlier and place the money needed for near-term expenses into a stable account.
That becomes a risk-management decision, not an attempt to predict whether stocks will rise or fall during the year.
Alternatively, retirees who use their IRAs for regular living expenses may simply take distributions monthly throughout the year.
An overlooked reason for taking the RMD earlier: death during the year
Suppose an 85-year-old normally waits until December to take his RMD but dies in September before taking it. If he died after his Required Beginning Date (RBD), the RMD obligation doesn’t simply disappear. His beneficiaries become responsible for completing the remaining year-of-death RMD.2
That can create an unnecessary administrative burden at an already difficult time. The beneficiaries may already be dealing with funeral arrangements, death certificates, estate administration, financial accounts, and other responsibilities.
For an older client—particularly someone in declining health, with multiple beneficiaries or multiple retirement accounts—taking the RMD earlier in the year may simplify matters for the family.
In certain situations and with current regulations, there may be relief if beneficiaries miss the year-of-death RMD deadline, but delaying it can potentially result in the beneficiary taking both the deceased owner’s remaining RMD and another inherited-account RMD in the following year, creating additional tax-planning considerations.
Don’t overlook QCDs
There is also an important reason not to rush to complete an RMD.
For IRA owners who are charitably inclined, a Qualified Charitable Distribution (QCD) can satisfy some or all of an RMD while excluding the qualifying distribution from income.
If someone completes the entire RMD in January and later decides to make charitable gifts from the IRA, those subsequent QCDs can still potentially qualify as QCDs, but they won’t retroactively replace the taxable RMD already taken. Consequently, someone contemplating charitable giving may want to coordinate QCDs before completing the RMD. This avoids any conflict with the “first-dollars-out rule,” which states that the first dollars withdrawn from an IRA are deemed to count toward the RMD. After an RMD is taken, it cannot be used to
retroactively offset a later QCD. Therefore, take your QCDs early to avoid a conflict with this situation.3
This is particularly relevant for clients who don’t determine their charitable giving until later in the year.
Tax withholding can affect timing too
IRA distributions can also be useful for tax withholding. One particularly valuable feature is that federal income tax withheld from an IRA distribution is generally treated as though it had been paid evenly throughout the year for estimated-tax purposes.
That can make a late-year IRA distribution useful when a retiree discovers that insufficient taxes have been paid during the year.
Therefore, tax planning may justify keeping some flexibility rather than automatically completing the RMD at the beginning of the year.
Don’t wait until December 31
Even when there is a reason to delay an RMD, waiting until the final days of December creates another kind of risk: administrative risk.
December is busy. Financial institutions experience high processing volumes, clients and advisors travel, charitable organizations need time to process contributions, and holidays shorten the practical working calendar. November may be the practical year-end time to take the RMD and ensure it is completed.
The financial-planning answer: It depends on your situation.
Rather than establishing one universal RMD date, it may make more sense to weigh out several circumstances together: your spending needs, health and longevity, number of beneficiaries and retirement accounts, charitable intentions, tax-withholding needs, and preference for simplicity.
In the sense that the government will get its tax revenue from IRA distributions, “everything does come out in the wash.” But you shouldn’t pay more in taxes than what is required.
Don’t take your RMD in December simply because that’s when you’ve always taken it. The timing of an RMD should be part of the retirement plan.
